What Makes a “Good” Patient?
Joan Naidorf, DO
May 8, 2025
Healthcare Administration Leadership & Management Journal
Volume 3, Issue 3, Pages 165-166
Abstract
The “ideal patient,” from the perspective of healthcare workers, emphasizes qualities such as independence, rationality, and compliance. These characteristics mirror what physicians and nurses value in themselves, leading to more effective and rewarding interactions. However, not all patients fit this mold, resulting in them being labeled “difficult” or “challenging.” The article delves into the ethical principles that underpin the clinician–patient relationship, including autonomy, beneficence, nonmaleficence, and justice, stressing that these principles must be upheld regardless of patient behavior. It further examines four models of physician–patient relationships — paternalistic, informative, interpretive, and deliberative, highlighting the complexities and ethical dilemmas inherent in medical practice.
Topics
Judgment
Self-Control
Adaptability
Related
Marshmallows and Medicine: The Psychology of Deferred GratificationHow to Recognize “Hidden Feedback”Mary Poppins Doesn't Exist: What Twenty-Two Au Pairs Taught Me About America's Care CrisisRecommended Reading
Self-Management
How to Recognize “Hidden Feedback”
Motivations and Thinking Style
Mary Poppins Doesn't Exist: What Twenty-Two Au Pairs Taught Me About America's Care Crisis
Motivations and Thinking Style
Lessons for Physicians from Huck Finn and Tom Sawyer
Professional Capabilities
“Profiles in Success”: Certified Physician Executives Share the Value and ROI of their CPE Education
Professional Capabilities
The Small Actions That Become Your Legacy