What Actually Sets High Achievers Apart?

Article

What Actually Sets High Achievers Apart?

While many high achievers rely on positive internal attributes, including intelligence, passion, and perseverance, research shows that external factors also play a big role in their success.

What sets high achievers apart from everyone else? This is the question that University of Pennsylvania professor Angela Duckworth has spent years trying to answer. While others might have focused on innate intelligence or talent, her research pointed her to grit: a combination of passion and perseverance that allows those who have it — or build it — to thrive. Her first book outlined how all of us can become more gritty.

More recently, however, Duckworth has found that achievers' ability to succeed with grit is meaningfully affected — both positively and negatively — by the situations in which they find or put themselves. For leaders, that means their work environments, relationships, and team and organizational cultures, and she notes that many of those factors are within our power to change.

Her new book is called Situated: Find the People and Places that Bring Out Your Best (Simon & Schuster, 2026), and I recently spoke with her by phone about how all of us can do just that. What follows is a lightly edited version of our conversation.

Alison Beard: How does where you're situated affect your ability to be gritty or not?

Angela Duckworth: Internal passion and perseverance has more to do with your external circumstances than you might imagine. We think that our intentions, our attitude, our feelings, and our behavior are internally directed — that we do what we want to do, think what we want to think. But much of that is triggered by who we're with and what we're around — our social and physical situation.

I don't think this is a contradiction to the importance of internal passion and perseverance. But it's clear that, in certain situations, we will be more passionate and persevering, and our effort will be more likely to pay off.

So is trying to change your situation potentially more effective than trying to change your mindset or behavior?

The highest-leverage thing you can do is to start with your situation. Of course, it is possible to directly change your mindset and thoughts. You could say: "I want to have a growth mindset. I want to be an optimist. I want to think positive thoughts about my colleagues today." Human beings are also able to directly change their behavior, whatever they're thinking: "Even though I'm feeling quite pessimistic about this, I will force myself to smile in this meeting."

But when you put yourself in a situation that helps you have the thoughts you want and generates the behavior you want — that's a better starting point. For example, if you feel cranky, you might ask yourself, "With which people, in which job tasks or projects, and in which physical settings am I more cheerful and confident?" Or if you're feeling imposter syndrome, you could say, "I'm not going to think those thoughts" or you could also call up a mentor who will say, "I believe in you. I know you can do this," and that is a situation that will trigger the thoughts and motivate the behavior that you want.

How can leaders better understand when their work situation, not a lack of motivation or willpower, is holding them back?

This goes back to the fundamental attribution error, which is well-documented across decades of social science research: When we try to puzzle out the behavior of others and ourselves, we tend to focus on the attributes of the person and not their circumstances. Situational awareness is bringing your attention to the external and taking it seriously.

I think we also live in a culture that equates internal will with moral character. Coming up in the business world, we're told to make the best of our circumstances. But you should also consider if your situation is working as an ally for you or not.

What's the biggest indication you're in a bad situation?

If you're burned out — which Christina Maslach, the Berkeley professor who coined the term, would say is the trifecta of feeling exhausted, detached, and powerless — that is an emotional response, which often comes from the thought "I am trying as hard as I can but not making progress." And, in one of the last articles she published, because she's now emeritus, she said that the bias is to fix the person, but most often what you need is to fix the situation: the job assignments, the team structure, the incentives, autonomy, community, alignment of values.

So that's the job of organizational leaders, but what can an individual do on their own to improve a bad situation?

I think the expression "control the controllables," which comes from sports, is also good advice in business. When people think about their professional situation, they often assume the whole thing can't be controlled and, sure, there's a very long list of situational realities that you can't do anything about.

But I would encourage people to make another list of aspects they can control, like what teams to volunteer for or whether or not to send an email to an admired colleague asking to have a conversation.

In your book you talk about using four levers to improve any situation, starting with space. Is changing your physical environment the best first step?

Yes, because it's the thing that almost everyone can do. The high achievers I've studied are very intentional about what's in their personal space and what's not.

For example, they remove distractions. I was recently on stage with Brad Stevens, general manager of the Celtics, and he mentioned that he has deleted certain apps from his phone. He cannot control the fact that social media exists or that there are lots of people who want to opine on his decisions, but he can control what he sees and pays attention to.

High achievers also add things to their personal space. I cannot tell you how many of them have a favorite quote engraved into wood or cast into pewter or hanging on a wall as a form of self-talk. That's so simple and doable, and it's effective. In season four of the TV show Ted Lasso, for example, there's a new female assistant coach who has Post-it notes with inspirational words all over the board above her desk. The idea is to edit your personal space so it includes the things you want to think about and doesn't include the things you should ignore. By the way, I have a life-sized cardboard cutout of Barack Obama on the third floor of our house, and every time I walk by it I think: "You know what? There's hope."

Let's talk about the relationships lever. How can leaders surround themselves with peers and mentors who make them better?

One case study that I teach in my MBA classes is on Toby Cosgrove, who became one of the greatest heart surgeons in the world despite profound, undiagnosed dyslexia. He was rejected by every medical school except for one. Everyone told him not to try cardiothoracic surgery because it's the most competitive specialty, but he did it anyway.

He is a paragon of grit. But he's also a paragon of situational agency. For example, when he transitioned from being a surgeon to being the CEO of the Cleveland Clinic, he had the good sense to reach out to people who knew more about leadership and business than he did, including Harvard Business School professor Michael Porter. And he found a long list of more experienced CEOs who were willing to mentor him, too. I do think it's important to find peers and mentors outside your own workplace. Whatever you're trying to do, you should be able to find a tribe.

Another lever is culture. Do individuals have the ability to change that in an organization?

Leaders certainly have disproportionate power. But I do think that anyone can shape their team's microculture. If you're always bringing humor or warmth or banana bread, that has an impact. But, if you're not in a position of authority, choosing the culture is just as important, provided you have the freedom to opt into teams or your company or industry.

Oftentimes we stick with what we have, even if we think things could be better elsewhere. But, as one leader said to me, "Sometimes fit looks a lot like grit." So I encourage people, particularly senior leaders, to find a culture where you feel like you can be your best.

Give me an example of an organizational or team leader taking a situation that wasn't great for their people and making it better through changes to space or peer and mentor relationships or culture.

Going back to Toby, he understood the importance of the physical. For example, the mantra of the Cleveland Clinic is putting patients first, so he rearranged the parking lot so the spaces closer to the front door were for patients, not physicians. He also wanted to make it easier for people from different specialties to collaborate, so he rearranged offices and org charts so that interdisciplinary teams were together and had their responsibilities intertwined. He set up what I believe is the longest standing mentoring program in academic medicine.

And, on culture, when Cleveland Clinic's patient experience was falling behind its excellent medical outcomes, he recruited a physician, Jim Merlino, whose father had died at the hospital, to improve things. And when Jim asked, "Will you let everybody off work for a half-day empathy exercise? It will cost $11 million," Toby said yes. That's a great example of what leaders need to do for their people. Ask: Have I set up their personal space? Have I picked their peers? Have I made mentorship the norm? And have I championed the culture carriers?

Copyright 2026 Harvard Business School Publishing Corporation. Distributed by The New York Times Syndicate.

Explore AAPL Membership benefits..

TopicsAdaptabilityJudgmentSelf-Control